Save this
Let me tell you about my top pick for a no-oven treat when it's hot outside—Orange Creamsicle Pie! This one brings back all those tasty orange-and-vanilla ice pops you couldn't get enough of as a kid, only this time it's in a rich, cozy pie. If turning on the oven sounds like too much on a sunny day, you're in the right place.
Chill Summer Vibes
This pie stands out because it nails that classic orange creamsicle vibe we all know and love. It's bright, cool, and creamy with just the right mix of citrus and smooth vanilla. Plus, you whip it up without baking, so it's a total lifesaver when the temperature climbs.
Stuff You Need
- The Creamy Stuff: - Heavy cream that makes it super fluffy - Orange Jell-O for bold flavor - Orange zest for a citrusy zing - Good ol' vanilla extract
- The Crust Stuff: - Grab a ready-made graham crust so you're not fussing - Cream cheese, brought to room temp, for that smooth feel - Powdered sugar to tie all the flavors together
Irresistible Pie Steps
- Finish Up:
- Cover the top with whipped cream swirls and a few orange slices if you want.
- Let It Chill:
- Pop the whole thing in the fridge overnight so it firms up nicely.
- Layer It Up:
- Spoon the cream cheese mixture in first, then pour in the orange layer right over it.
- Mix It All Together:
- Gently fold the whipped cream into both the Jell-O and the cheesy mixtures.
- Whip Time:
- Beat the cream with sugar and vanilla until it gets all soft and pillowy.
- Orange Prep:
- Stir your Jell-O into hot water and let it hang out until cool.
- Cheese First:
- Whip up the cream cheese and stir in powdered sugar until everything's nice and smooth.
Make It Yours
Want more zing? Toss in even more zest or a little fresh squeezed orange. Craving something new? Swap the crust for vanilla wafers. Every so often, I'll sprinkle on tiny marshmallows or double up on whipped cream for a fancier look.
Save this
Simple Summer Highlight
Every time I serve this, people light up. It's perfect for a cookout, birthday, or just beating the heat. Only problem is, waiting for it to firm up in the fridge is almost impossible!
Common Questions
- → How come my pie won’t firm up?
Chill it at least overnight if you want it firm. Make sure you blend all your fillings together well before stacking.
- → Can I swap in light cream cheese or cream?
You’ll get the best texture using regular, full-fat cream cheese and heavy cream. Lighter options might come out softer or not hold together as well.
- → Why are my pretty layers getting mixed together?
Let each part chill in the fridge a bit before you spoon the next on top. Go slow adding each layer so they stay separate.
- → Is it okay to freeze the whole thing?
Totally fine—stash it in the freezer for up to 3 months. Whenever you’re ready, move it to the fridge to thaw overnight.
- → Will it last for days in the fridge?
Yep, it keeps up to 5 days chilled. Add the whipped cream topping right before you slice and serve.