Save this
Years of trial and error led me to this brown sugar caramel frosting. I wanted a caramel that didn’t taste just sweet, but brought out bold flavor with brown sugar and creamy butter. Now it’s the one everyone begs for. It makes anything you put it on taste just unreal.
Why You’ll Love This Frosting
This frosting is stupid fast to make, but tastes like you put way more work into it. That deep caramel taste and smooth finish turn even the plainest treat into something awesome. You can make it runny or thick—top cookies, swirl between cake layers, or drizzle on cinnamon buns.
All the Good Stuff
- Butter: I pick unsalted so I can choose how salty to go.
- Brown Sugar: The real secret for that caramel kick.
- Powdered Sugar: Use as much as you want—thin or thick is up to you.
- Vanilla Extract: A little really bumps up the taste.
- Milk: Whole milk is extra rich, but honestly any kind is fine.
Whip It Up
- Finish With Vanilla:
- Last step, stir in the vanilla so that sweet smell pops.
- Fluff It Up:
- Whisk in the powdered sugar until the texture is just how you want it.
- Let It Cool:
- After bubbling, pull it off the heat and let it cool until just warm.
- Add Milk Gently:
- Slowly pour in milk, keep stirring, and bring it to a soft boil.
- Get Things Melting:
- Start by melting butter over low, then toss in brown sugar and stir till it melts.
Gotta-Try Tricks
- Warm It Again: If it’s too stiff, just reheat slowly, stirring as you go.
- Tweak Texture: More powdered sugar for thicker, splash a bit of milk if it’s too stiff.
- Move Quick: It sets fast—get that cake or pan ready first.
- Go for the Good Stuff: Tasty butter and fresh brown sugar make all the magic happen.
Save this
Switch Things Up
- Brown Sugar Swap: Dark brown makes it bold, light brown keeps it soft and light.
- Keep It Chilled: Pop in the fridge for three days, just rewarm before spreading.
- Freeze Ahead: Goes in the freezer for about a month, let it thaw and gently heat to use.
- Try It Everywhere: Smother it on brownies, swirl on cookies, or slather cake—can't go wrong.
Common Questions
- → Why does my frosting sometimes turn gritty?
Don’t forget to keep stirring over gentle heat till the brown sugar melts right into the butter. If you rub some between your fingers, there shouldn’t be any crunch left.
- → Is it okay to prep this frosting before you need it?
Sure, make it the day before. Just pop it in the fridge, then when you're ready, let it warm up and whip it again so it spreads nicely.
- → What made my frosting go rock-hard?
As it cools, it’ll stiffen up on its own. If it’s a brick, give it a bit of heat and mix in a splash of milk till it's nice and spreadable.
- → Will this frosting survive the freezer?
You can freeze it for a few months. Defrost slow in the fridge overnight, then let it warm up and beat it again to get it smooth.
- → How much can I cover with this frosting?
This batch is more than enough for 24 cupcakes or a 9-inch cake with some extra in case you want to add fancy swirls.