Irresistible Party Mushrooms

As seen on: Easy Appetizer and Snack Recipes

These filled caps feature small portabellas topped with a decadent mix of soft cheese, grated parmesan, fresh greenery and crispy crumbs for a fancy bite-sized snack.

emilyscooks.com
Shared By Emily
Last revised on Fri, 18 Apr 2025 20:35:34 GMT
A plate of stuffed portobello mushrooms topped with golden breadcrumbs and garnished with chopped parsley. Save this
A plate of stuffed portobello mushrooms topped with golden breadcrumbs and garnished with chopped parsley. | emilyscooks.com

I wanna tell you about my top pick for Stuffed Mushrooms - they're just awesome for when people come over. You'll love these soft mushroom caps loaded with rich cheese, garden-fresh herbs and crunchy breadcrumbs. They've become my number one starter that gets compliments every time.

Crowd Pleaser

Fantastic starter both relaxed and fancy. Every mouthful brings earthy, cheesy goodness.

Essential Components

  • Mushrooms: Go for cremini or baby bella
  • Cream Cheese: Softened for easy mixing
  • Parmesan: Newly grated for kick
  • Breadcrumbs: Standard or gluten free works
  • Fresh Herbs: Pick parsley or cilantro

Simple Instructions

Get Mushrooms Ready
Wipe caps, take out stems, pat dry
Prepare Filling
Fry stems with garlic and shallots
Combine Mixture
Stir herbs with crumbs and cheeses
Stuff and Bake
Fill caps until brown on top

Winning Tricks

Don't wash mushrooms in water. Just wipe them clean for top outcome.

A plate of stuffed mushrooms topped with golden breadcrumbs and garnished with parsley. Save this
A plate of stuffed mushrooms topped with golden breadcrumbs and garnished with parsley. | emilyscooks.com

Plan Ahead

Get filling ready early and keep apart. Fill and cook when guests arrive.

Save Properly

Pop in sealed container in fridge. Better eaten within five days.

Save Unbaked

Stick unbaked ones in freezer. Good for two months no problem.

Save After Cooking

Let cool then put in freezer. Warm in oven to get crunch back.

Pick Smartly

Go for mid-sized caps. They handle stuffing and eating well.

A platter of stuffed mushrooms topped with crispy breadcrumbs and garnished with chopped herbs. Save this
A platter of stuffed mushrooms topped with crispy breadcrumbs and garnished with chopped herbs. | emilyscooks.com

Wheat-Free

Switch to gluten free breadcrumbs. Tweak quantity to get right feel.

Dairy Swap

Play with different cheese blends. Aged or strong ones taste best.

Green Touch

Try thyme, parsley or cilantro. Dried or fresh both do the job.

Great Pairing

Team with drinks at get-togethers. Fits nicely in a light snack spread.

Festive Touch

Classy party starter for celebrations. They're always gone in minutes.

A plate of stuffed mushrooms topped with breadcrumbs and parsley, with more mushrooms in the background. Save this
A plate of stuffed mushrooms topped with breadcrumbs and parsley, with more mushrooms in the background. | emilyscooks.com

Extra Crunch

Use flat tray not deep dish. Makes them crunchy not mushy.

Mix It Up

Throw in crab or sausage bits. Match seasonings with your add-ins.

Heat Again

Use your oven to reheat them. Keeps them tasty and firm.

Look Good

Put them on a nice plate with herb sprinkles. Looks wow with little work.

Simple Favorite

A starter that never goes out of style. Works for any party or meet-up.

A platter of baked stuffed mushrooms topped with golden cheese and herbs. Save this
A platter of baked stuffed mushrooms topped with golden cheese and herbs. | emilyscooks.com

Common Questions

→ What's the best way to wash mushrooms?

You can give them a quick splash under water and dry them right away, or just wipe with a damp paper towel. Never let them sit in water as they'll soak it up like sponges.

→ Can I prep these before my event?

Absolutely! Get them ready and filled up to 24 hours early. Keep them wrapped in the fridge and pop them in the oven right before your guests arrive.

→ How can I make these without gluten?

Switch to gluten-free crumbs but add an extra 2 tablespoons since they're usually lighter than regular ones.

→ Can I swap out the herbs?

For sure! Don't like cilantro? Try parsley instead. Any fresh greens that go well with mushrooms will taste great.

→ How long will extras last?

Put them in a sealed container in your fridge and they'll be good for 3-5 days. Just warm them up quickly in the microwave.

Wrap-Up

Smooth, flavor-packed mushroom bites that'll wow at any get-together. Quick to put together and sure to disappear fast.

Cheese-Filled Mushroom Caps

Mini portabellas packed with a smooth blend of dairy, spices and toasted crumbs - the ultimate gathering treat.

Preparation Time
15 Minutes
Cooking Time
30 Minutes
Overall Time
45 Minutes
Shared By: Emily

Meal Type: Appetizers & Snacks

Skill Level: Moderate

Cuisine Style: American

Makes: 4 Portions (16 stuffed mushrooms)

Special Diet: Low in Carbs, Vegetarian-Friendly

What You’ll Need

01 items 1 pound medium baby bella or portobello mushrooms
02 items 2 tbsp olive oil for coating mushrooms
03 items Stems from mushrooms, saved for filling
04 items 1 tbsp olive oil for cooking
05 items 1 whole shallot
06 items 3 cloves of garlic
07 items 1 tbsp fresh chopped cilantro
08 items 4 oz softened cream cheese
09 items 1 whole egg
10 items 1/4 cup dry bread crumbs
11 items 1/2 cup freshly shredded Parmesan
12 items Salt
13 items Black pepper
14 items 2-4 tbsp extra Parmesan for garnish

Steps To Make It

Step 01

Heat your oven to 350°F. Wipe mushrooms clean, pop out stems and coat caps with oil.

Step 02

Cook chopped shallot and mushroom stems till soft. Throw in garlic and cook till you can smell it.

Step 03

Stir together the cooled veggie mix with cream cheese, bread crumbs, Parmesan, cilantro, egg, salt and pepper.

Step 04

Spoon the mixture into each mushroom cap, lightly pressing down.

Step 05

Put in oven for 20-25 minutes until the mushrooms are soft and tops turn golden. Sprinkle with remaining cheese.

Extra Notes

  1. You can make these a day ahead
  2. Feel free to swap in parsley if you don't like cilantro
  3. They'll stay good in the fridge for 3-5 days

Essential Tools

  • Shallow baking dish
  • Small frying pan

Allergen Info

Review ingredients carefully for allergens, and consult a healthcare provider if you're unsure.
  • Dairy products in cream cheese and parmesan
  • Eggs
  • Wheat found in bread crumbs

Nutritional Info (Per Serving)

Keep in mind, this data is an estimate and not a substitute for professional dietary advice.
  • Calories: 324
  • Fat Content: 26 grams
  • Total Carbs: 13 grams
  • Protein Content: 12 grams