Save this
My family calls this Cheesy Pizza Casserole their top comfort food pick. It brings together all the good stuff we love about pizza—stretchy cheese, tasty meat, tangy sauce—and turns it into the most snuggly casserole you'll ever try. I whip this up when we're crazy busy or when friends swing by, and it never fails to wow everyone.
What Makes This So Irresistible
This casserole stands out because it's super easy to put together—just what you need when you're running late but want something warm and filling. My kids jump up and down when they smell it cooking, and honestly, who can turn down those stretchy cheese pulls and classic pizza taste?
Shop For These Items
- Farfalle Pasta: 1 pound only cooked to al dente so it stays firm in your dish
- Mild Pork Sausage: 1 pound for that rich taste backbone
- Fresh Garlic: 2 cloves finely chopped cause food just tastes better with it
- Onion: 1 medium chopped into small bits for extra flavor
- Oregano: 1 teaspoon dried the must-have pizza herb
- Spaghetti Sauce: 3 cups grab whatever brand you like best
- Ham: 1 cup diced small for that extra savory kick
- Pepperoni: 1 cup cause you can't skip this pizza classic
- Mozzarella: 16 ounces grated fresh for that perfect stretch
- Parmesan: 6 tablespoons freshly grated to punch up the flavor
Cooking Steps
- First Things First
- I start by heating my oven to 375°F and giving my 9×13 pan a quick oil spray. While cooking my pasta, I cook up the sausage with the onions, garlic, and oregano in a big pan—your kitchen will smell fantastic.
- Creating Your Stack
- My top trick is spreading a thin sauce layer on the bottom first. Then stack it like this: one-third pasta, sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, and your cooked sausage mix. Do this three times and save the ham and pepperoni for scattering on top where they'll get nice and crisp.
- Finishing Up
- Stick it in the oven without covering for around 40 minutes until it's hot and bubbling away. It'll be hard, but let it sit for 5-10 minutes before digging in—it'll taste even better, I promise.
Custom Touches
What's great about this dish? You can totally switch things up. I sometimes throw in some mushrooms or peppers, and my daughter can't get enough black olives on hers. Try different meats too—ground beef works great, or go lighter with some turkey. And don't get me started on all the different cheeses you could try.
Save this
Prep In Advance
Here's a game-changer tip—I often put this together the night before when I know tomorrow's gonna be crazy. It stays perfect in your fridge for up to 3 days or tuck it in the freezer for up to 3 months. Just remember you'll need to cook it longer if it's coming straight from cold storage.
Store What's Left
If you're lucky enough to have some left, it'll keep nicely in your fridge for about 5 days. I like to split it into lunch-sized containers for quick meals—just a minute in the microwave does the trick. For family servings, I pop it back in the oven so the cheese gets all melty again.
Crockpot Version
When I don't want to heat up the kitchen, I reach for my slow cooker. Put everything in the same way, then let it cook on low for about 3-4 hours. Just watch those edges since slow cookers can sometimes get hotter in certain spots.
Children Love It
My little ones go crazy for this meal—they think it's better than pizza night! They love to help stack all the goodies and watch the cheese bubble through the oven window. We've made it our end-of-week tradition now.
Round Out Your Table
We usually pair this with a fresh green salad on the side. Some buttery garlic bread works great too—perfect for scooping up any sauce left on your plate. When we're feeling fancy, the adults might enjoy a small glass of red wine to make it feel like an Italian restaurant at home.
Heating Leftovers
When it's time to eat the leftovers, I always use my oven at 350°F. I cover it with foil so it stays moist, then take the foil off for the last few minutes to get that cheese bubbly again. Sometimes I think it tastes even better the next day!
Save this
Crowd Pleaser
Whenever I bring this to get-togethers, folks can't get enough. It's got all those pizza flavors everybody craves but in a dish that's easy to share. Plus it stays hot for ages—just what you want for those long family gatherings.
Dietary Swaps
Got friends who can't have gluten? I've tried it with gluten-free pasta and it turns out great. For folks avoiding dairy, there are some really good cheese alternatives now. Just check your sausage ingredients carefully and you're all set.
Party Ready
This is my go-to dish for sharing. I use those throwaway aluminum trays when I'm taking it somewhere to keep things easy. Just wrap it up good with foil to trap the heat during travel and it'll still be warm and tasty when you get there.
Add Some Heat
Sometimes we want it with a bit more kick. I'll toss in some crushed red pepper or swap in spicy Italian sausage instead of mild. Hot pepperoni on top is awesome too—just match the spice level to what your family can handle.
Individual Servings
I'm a fan of making smaller versions in little oven-safe dishes—perfect when everyone wants their own mix of toppings. They look so adorable and work great for dinner parties, plus everyone gets those yummy crispy edges all around.
Stock Your Freezer
I always cook two batches at once—one for dinner tonight and one for later. It saves so much time. Just wrap it tight with plastic and foil, write the date and cooking instructions on top. You'll thank yourself on those busy nights ahead.
Save this
Elevated Version
When company's coming, I'll tuck fresh basil and sun-dried tomatoes between the layers. A little drizzle of thick balsamic glaze right before serving really wows everyone. These tiny changes make it feel extra special without much extra work.
Cook Together
Making this dish is fun for the whole family at our house. Everyone gets to add their favorite bits to their corner of the pan. The kids get so creative with it, and they always eat better when they've helped cook the meal.
Fast Dinner Fix
This casserole is my backup plan for crazy weeknights. It comes together so fast with stuff I usually have around anyway. Plus it fills everyone up and might even leave some for tomorrow's lunch boxes.
Healthier Option
When we're watching what we eat, I use whole wheat pasta, turkey sausage, and cut back on the cheese a bit. I load it up with veggies like spinach and zucchini for extra nutrition, and nobody misses the extra calories at all.
Creative Extras
Got some left? Try stuffing it into bell peppers or pile it onto garlic bread for amazing sandwiches the next day. Sometimes I even sprinkle it on top of fresh pizza dough for a mind-blowing pizza-on-pizza creation.
Works For Any Occasion
From regular Tuesday dinners to big game day parties, this dish always hits the spot. It's my reliable choice when I need something everyone will enjoy. That mix of comfort food feel and amazing flavor just can't be topped.
Save this
Common Questions
- → Can I put this together beforehand?
- Sure thing! You can get everything ready up to a day early. Just wrap it up and stick it in the fridge, then add about 10-15 extra minutes when you pop it in the oven.
- → Will this dish freeze well?
- Absolutely! You can freeze it cooked or uncooked for up to 3 months. Just let it thaw in your fridge overnight before you heat it up or finish cooking it.
- → What if I want to swap out the meat?
- Feel free to throw in whatever pizza toppings you love! Try some bell peppers, mushrooms, or olives to make it veggie-friendly, or switch to ground turkey or beef if you want.
- → Which pasta shapes work in this?
- The recipe mentions farfalle, but any medium pasta will do the trick. Try rotini, penne, or ziti - they're all great at grabbing onto that tasty sauce.
- → Why should I wait before digging in?
- Letting it sit for 5-10 minutes helps everything firm up a bit. This makes it way easier to dish out without everything sliding around on your plate.